Choosing between two Goulds 3196 i-Frame centrifugal pumps for industrial water flow control comes down to a $5,300 gap and a very different set of contents. One unit is a used, pump-only 316SS design; the other is a new surplus pump-and-motor assembly rated for 199.9 GPM. If you already have a motor and baseplate, the used pump could be the smarter spend. If you want a ready-to-run package, the new surplus assembly is the one to consider. Here's the head-to-head.
Quick Verdict
For a bare 316SS process pump with an 8-inch impeller, the used Goulds 3196 i-Frame at $2,200 is the lower-price choice. For a complete Goulds 3196 i-Frame package with ductile iron casing, 316SS wetted parts, and a 5HP 3-phase motor, the new surplus assembly at $7,500 offers a ready-to-run option. The $5,300 price spread reflects more than condition-it pays for the motor and the completed pump-motor assembly.
Comparison Table
| Aspect | Used Pump (1x1.5-8 316SS) | New Surplus Assembly (3x4-8G with 5HP Motor) |
|---|---|---|
| Listed price | USD 2,200.00 | USD 7,500.00 |
| Condition | Used | New - Open box |
| Contents | Pump only | no motor or baseplate included | Complete pump and motor assembly |
| Construction | 316SS construction | Ductile iron casing with 316SS wetted parts |
| Pump size | 1x1.5-8 with 8\" impeller | 3x4-8G with 6.5\" impeller |
| Motor | None included | 5HP 3-phase | 208-230/460V | 1750 RPM |
| Flow rating | Not listed | 199.9 GPM at 33.9 ft head |
Where Each Wins
The used pump wins for price-conscious buyers who have their own motor and mounting setup and want a 316SS process pump. The new surplus assembly wins for buyers who need a matched, ready-to-run centrifugal pump with a specified 5HP motor and published flow rating.
Goulds 3196 i-Frame 1x1.5-8 316SS (Used)
This used Goulds 3196 i-Frame is priced at $2,200 and is a pump-only unit-no motor, no baseplate, no coupling. It features 316SS construction, size 1x1.5-8, and an 8-inch impeller. If you already have a suitable motor and mounting setup, this is the lower-price route to a Goulds process pump. Its limitation is that it comes as a bare pump, so you will need to source and align the motor and baseplate yourself. The condition is used, not new, so expect it to show signs of prior service. It is listed as a water-type pump made in Canada, and it is the price entry point in this pair.
Goulds Pumps 3196 3x4-8G i-Frame with 5HP Motor (New Surplus)
This new surplus Goulds Pumps 3196 i-Frame is priced at $7,500 and sold as a complete pump and motor assembly. It has a ductile iron casing with 316SS wetted parts, and the pump is rated for 199.9 GPM at 33.9 ft head. The motor is a 5HP, 3-phase unit at 208-230/460V, 1750 RPM. If you want a matched, ready-to-run package for chemical, municipal, or industrial transfer applications, this assembly addresses that need without separate motor shopping. The trade-off is the higher price-$5,300 more than the used pump. It is listed as new - open box, with a 3x4-8G size and 6.5-inch impeller, and it was built in Canada.
Final Choice by Use Case
If you already have a 3-phase motor and a baseplate, the used pump at $2,200 is the lower-price way to get a Goulds 3196 i-Frame 316SS pump. If you need a complete, new-surplus Goulds 3196 i-Frame assembly with a 5HP motor and a rated 199.9 GPM output, the $7,500 package is the one to weigh. For a one-to-one replacement of a pump-only unit, the used 1x1.5-8 316SS makes sense; for a new installation where you want a matched motor, the new surplus 3x4-8G is the complete answer.
