Quick Verdict
Your first decision is whether you need a motor alone or a motor-and-reducer package. The Baldor-Reliance VEM3558T + Dodge Quantis combines a TEFC motor with a right-angle helical-bevel speed reducer; the 1800 RPM 5 HP Severe Duty TEFC Motor is a standalone motor. Priced at $700.00 and $330.95, the spread is $369.05. If your application calls for integrated speed reduction and a 208-230/460 V motor, choose the Baldor-Reliance combo. If you want a new severe-duty 5 HP motor with 50/60 Hz flexibility and a lighter price, choose the standalone 1800 RPM motor.
At a Glance
| Consideration | Baldor-Reliance VEM3558T + Dodge Quantis | 1800 RPM 5 HP Severe Duty Motor |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $700.00 | $330.95 |
| Condition | New - Open box | New |
| Motor voltage | 208-230/460 V AC | 230/460 V AC |
| Frequency rating | 60 Hz | 50/60 Hz |
| Motor features | NEMA C-Face, TEFC, Class F insulation | 184T frame, TEFC/IP55, Class F insulation |
| Included hardware | Motor plus Dodge Quantis reducer (5.65:1, 1019 in-lb) | Motor only |
Where the Baldor-Reliance combo wins
- Integrated speed reduction: The Dodge Quantis reducer is part of the package, with a 5.65:1 ratio and max output torque of 1019 in-lb. No separate gearbox sourcing needed.
- C-Face motor format: The NEMA C-Face motor is designed to couple with driven equipment, and the package already includes the mating reducer.
- Broader voltage input: The 208-230/460 V rating supports 208 V, 230 V, and 460 V supplies; the standalone motor is listed for 230/460 V only.
Where the standalone motor wins
- Broader frequency compatibility: It's rated for 50/60 Hz, while the Baldor combo is listed for 60 Hz only.
- New condition: The motor is listed as New, while the combo is New - Open box.
- Severe-duty details: 5 HP, 184T frame, TEFC/IP55 enclosure, 1.15 service factor, Class F insulation, 1800 RPM, and a 1-1/8-inch keyed shaft.
Product Notes
Baldor-Reliance VEM3558T + Dodge Quantis
If output speed needs to be dropped after the motor, this package shortens the project: the included Dodge Quantis BB383CN140TC right-angle helical-bevel reducer offers a 5.65:1 ratio and 1019 in-lb max output torque, so you don't have to match a reducer to a motor shaft on your own. The Baldor-Reliance motor is TEFC with Class F insulation and a NEMA C-Face configuration, and the 208-230/460 V listing supports a wider range of supply voltages. The honest trade-off is condition: this unit is listed as New - Open box, so it isn't factory-sealed. It is also rated for 60 Hz only, which matters if your site runs on 50 Hz. Choose this when speed reduction is the priority and your supply is 60 Hz.
1800 RPM 5 HP Electric Motor
This motor is the standalone workhorse: 5 HP in a severe-duty 184T frame, with a TEFC/IP55 enclosure, Class F insulation, and a 1.15 service factor for overload headroom. It handles both 50 Hz and 60 Hz inputs and can be wired for 230 V or 460 V, giving you more flexibility if equipment may move between facilities or supplies. The 1800 RPM output and 1-1/8-inch keyed shaft suit it for pumps, compressors, conveyors, and similar rotating equipment. Since this listing is motor-only, you'd add any speed reduction or coupling hardware separately. At 104 pounds, it's a heavy unit to position, so lifting equipment should be part of your plan. Choose this when you need a new, capable motor and already have the rest of the drivetrain sorted.
Final Choice by Use Case
- Choose the Baldor-Reliance VEM3558T + Dodge Quantis when you need a motor-plus-reducer assembly, right-angle output, and 208-230/460 V supply flexibility, and you're comfortable with an open-box unit on a 60 Hz system.
- Choose the 1800 RPM 5 HP Severe Duty Motor when you need a new, heavy-duty 5 HP motor for direct-drive applications, want 50/60 Hz compatibility, and plan to handle any speed reduction or coupling separately.
